Business as a Moral Enterprise
Commerce. Hubbub. The noisy marketplace. The tens, hundreds, and thousands of small exchanges. In the store, online, over the phone, from an airplane. Itâs like an ecology, the ecology of the economy. The creation and shifting of resources from one area of the ecology to another. All voluntarily. All based on what we value, on what we think is worth the expending and spending of resources. The values, where do they come from?
As entrepreneurs, we design âthe value exchanges:â those interactions that bring together buyers, workers, suppliers, owners, and indirectly, their surrounding environments. If weâve done our job well, each party leaves the exchange with greater value than they brought to it. In a very real sense, they are affirmed in that value through their interactions with the others. The whole process is a way of cooperating to make the imaginary real, the potential actual, the unseen seen. It also transcends the laws of matter: while the physical matter doesnât increase, paradoxically the whole enchilada just grew, because it grew in a non-material dimension: in the minds and souls of the participating parties.

âThe value exchangesâ are preceded by a decision, and the savvy entrepreneur is really a decision architect. Sheâs created the exchange, but the decision is what gets the movement of the exchange activated. Architecting that decision is really a matter of leadership, of presenting the decider with their freedom. The frame of the decision proposes a truth about reality, what makes reality better, and how the exchange brings about that reality.
Boiling Down An Accounting Firm
The world is a wild and wooly place. Grappling order out of chaos, or introducing chaos into order, is a messy business. Which is why neatness is not the aim of business, even though we may sometimes consider it the aim of accounting.
In our efforts to come to terms with our reality, mental models can be very helpful. The concept of business as a ship, navigating uncharted waters, in search of undiscovered lands. Or that of climbing a mountain, catching glimpses of the peak, pressing on, but enjoying the journey. Or as we like talk about in Thriveal, cliff-jumping, blowing stuff up, and lab experiments on our way to making a new firm. These can help give us the clarity and impetus to act because we have a way to understand our movements in the broader story.
Conversely, mental models can also be very harmful. The idea of time as money. That monetary profits are the sole purpose of business. That perfection of the system is the goal (thus people become cogs in the machine). That leaders are all-knowing and inerrant. These are among the models that can increase our friction as they under-equip us to deal with the realities we face.
Our ability to evolve and change is usually the result of adopting a new mental model and/or letting go of an old mental model. Theyâre the brain pathways that sit just underneath the surface, often out of view to us. Theyâre the pattern molds weâre subconsciously using to make sense of and interpret the experiences we have each day. You can see how powerful they are to our life. Itâs why I take issue with the phrase âperception is realityâ and prefer to replace it with âperception shapes our experience of reality.â
Accounting Enters the Creative Economy
This post is adapted from a presentation I gave at Xerocon Denver 2015. In it, I talked about the progression our economy has made from agrarian, to industrial, to service, to knowledge, to what I believe is here in some industries, and now surfacing in the accounting industry â the creative economy. See this link if youâd like to read the full text.
If you look at our nationâs history, youâll notice the progression from survival (agrarian economy), to possessions (industrial economy), to freed up time (services economy), to intellectual pursuits (knowledge economy). Some of you may recognize the parallel to Maslowâs hierarchy of needs. I suggest we as a society, and as an economy, are moving our way up that hierarchy.
So what comes next? I believe thereâs a new age brewing â itâs been around for a little in the broader market actually. But I believe our field, accounting, is now entering the creative economy. In this landscape, itâs not acres, itâs not physical capital, itâs not hours, and itâs not even intellectual property that governs the economic paradigm: itâs our ability to tap into the human capacity to imagine and create. Thatâs what the market will reward the greatest. And thatâs why the largest taxi company doesnât own a single vehicle (Uber), one of the largest lodging companies doesnât own a single building (Airbnb), and the largest content company doesnât have any journalists (Facebook).
The next ten years or so, I believe, will be a drama between the characters of Knowledge (weâll call him Kevin), and Creativity (weâll call her Cora) â something I call, âThe Tale of Two Economies.â
The Two Most Important Numbers Arenât on Your Income Statement
Iâve suggested before that accounting is not the language of business, but that I do think CPAs bring unique abilities to the conversation of business. In a world of information, perspective is king, and if we can see our finances in their broader context, I think we go a long way to growing stronger.
To that end, Iâd like to propose that your (and any other businessâ) two most important numbers donât appear on your income statement: (1) customer profit, and (2) opportunity loss. This graphic helps illustrate:

Transformative Systems
Systems are so important as enabling mechanisms. Sometimes I like to call them âstructures of freedom.â Iâm reminded of a quote from Tim Williams at Thrivealâs Deeper Weekend last fall, âProcess is the architecture for getting things done.â Even creative processes, like transforming your firm, require some level of scaffolding to help you see it through from concept to realization.
Systems can compete with each other too. The system you know and use now will almost always beat out the one thatâs fledgling or undefined. This is why itâs almost always easier to spend hours replying to e-mails than to change your firm. Thereâs a system for e-mail, but not for transformation.
So our goal is to develop a creative system for our firm, shield it during its fledgling stage, and then let it grow to become part of our way of doing things, that stands its ground and evidences its value as part of our firmâs operations.
Cracking this nut is not easy. But I feel like I took another step earlier this year in my own personal system.
Brands Donât Really Exist
Over the years, Iâve developed a skepticism of brands, a healthy one I hope. And I would venture to say you have too. One ad after another, all making claims to be the best thing ever. Common sense tells us it canât actually be â we all want to believe that particular cologne/perfume is going to make us instantly magnetic, but we know better. And then thereâs one purchase after another; many donât live up to the hype, some do, some do to begin with, but donât last. Each of these experiences eats away at our ability to believe, to trust.
Brands can be so impersonal â marketing messages connect us to the brand, and humans become merely the means to get to the brand. Ads create a desire for Cheerios, and supermarkets and checkout registers are just a delivery mechanism to acquire Cheerios for ourselves. The quicker and easier, the better. Products, not humans, are the end. (Or perhaps more accurately, the emotional state promised by the products.)
But brands are real, right? I mean, after all, thereâs Coca-Cola, Apple, Southwest, and Rolls Royce. They must truly exist. Or do they? Maybe theyâre just made up. Maybe they only exist simply because we all agree they exist. Sorta like language â we all agree this scrawled shape on a piece of paper constitutes a letter, âdâ weâll call it. And we agree that it makes a particular, recognizable sound formed by our mouths and tongues. And when combined with the two other scrawled shapes âoâ and âg,â signifies those panting, four-legged furry creatures in our homes.
JetPack Workflow: On Being an Entrepreneurial Accountant
You may recognize JetPack Workflow as a provider of simple client and workflow management software. It was fun to join David Cristello in their podcast to talk about being an entrepreneurial accountant, where we covered topics like the psychological shift needed to prepare for the future of accounting, the importance of taking breaks (and how to take them, even in tax season), and tips for how to be an entrepreneurial accountant.
You can catch the audio and show notes on the episode page, plus check out their podcast on iTunes or other podcatcher (additional links on the episode page).
And be sure to swing by JetPack’s website if you’re curious to see how their workflow solution works.
The Future Takes Time
Itâs right before tax season, and Iâm sitting here at a table in my officeâs front room, typing away on my laptop. This moment has significance.
We moved into this office space in February 2012, right as tax season started that year. It came after an unexpected offer to change suites at our office park to a ground floor spot. Itâs not a big space, 1100 square feet +/Â. But I got to design the floor plan and had been working with the contractors on buildÂout, colors, flooring, network placement, etc. There was a concept then for how we wanted to decorate the front room, but we had to settle for the basics at the time so we could go full swing into tax season.
And now itâs three years later. And weâve decorated the front room to welcome our customers into a relaxing coffee shop style feel that was its original plan. And Iâm sitting at a pubÂ-style table here.
The future takes time.
This quote from Reid Hoffman I think is critical for those of us out there trying to do something new:
âInnovation comes from long term thinking and iterative execution.â
Referring Link: Three Experiments to Try in 2015
I announced the Thriveal Lab’s “3 Experiments to Try” for 2015, which included: (a) coffee coach each of your team members, (b) prototype your evolved business model, and (c) donât send tax organizers to customers.
For more details, related resources, and more, check out the original post on the Thriveal blog.
Referring Link: Experiment 1 Lab Report Released
I’m happy and proud to release the official Lab Report for the first experiment conducted by the Thriveal Lab: Business Model Prototyping. In this post on the Thriveal blog, I announce the release, embed a video of webcast we had to release it to the profession, and provide a number of links to download your copy and also to continue the experiment using the tools of the Self-Experiment Initiative. A big day!
Thrivecast: Secret Stash
Each December the Thrivecast releases its “Secret Stash” episodes, which are previously unreleased snippets from all of their guests during the year. As a follow-up from my August 2014 interview, the December Thrivecast contained a secret stash snippet where I talked about the genesis of the value accounting model I was working on.
You can listen to the audio right from the page for Episode 42 with yours truly starting at 1:00:50, and of course catch their podcast in your favorite podcatcher.
Referring Link: Become a Thriveal Lab Partner!
As the Thriveal Lab gained steam and was concluding its first experiment, we reached out to continue to build our base of supporters who were organized in what we called Lab Partners (a nice high school reference). ;)
In this post on the Thriveal blog, we reiterated the mission of the Lab, sounded the call for partners, and listed the special benefits they would receive.
Reflections After 3 Years of Value Pricing
I met Ron Baker in person for the first time in 2011. Before that, I had read his articles online and attended a webinar he presented. But in 2011, I attended the first Thriveal Deeper Weekend, which was a âFirm of the Futureâ seminar offered by Ron Baker and Ed Kless. That was two days of brain-crushing, mind-altering, future-shifting learning and dialogue.
I immediately started to change things: first with a handful of customers with whom we had strong relationships, then with certain service types, etc. I remember a year later, Iâd hardly made the progress I wanted to, and was feeling down wondering if it was ever going to happen. I remember chatting with Ron around that time, and he mentioned in passing that firms usually take three years to fully transition to value pricing. Whew â I was much relieved: I still had time.
Three years later, I look back, and boy, there has been such a change between then and now. Iâm happy to say, weâre now completely value priced â Iâm still learning (and doubt Iâll ever stop), but I feel so much more freed as a business owner having gone through this process. I was recently reflecting on some of the realizations Iâve had along the way and wanted to share them with you:
CPAs Should Own the Profit Equation
Great things can be accomplished by teams. And the best teams are made up of players who have unique roles that mesh and multiply their teammates.
What is the unique role of the CPA? The thing we bring to the table of business?
I propose that CPAs should own the âprofit equationâ â that it be our domain.
Be Aware of Your Cognitive Dissonance
As a small business owner, you have one foot in the future and one foot in the the present: building your firm for the future, while serving the needs of the present. The difference between the two worlds is the gap: the space between where you are and where youâll be. If you let that gap grow too big while your feet are straddling itâŠwell, I think you get the picture. đ
In some ways, that gap is what defines an entrepreneur. They see the difference between the world how it is and how it can be. Itâs an internal cognitive dissonance, a type of itch, that they reach out to scratch.
What can happen nowadays, though, is that so much innovation comes at us, that the volume of cognitive dissonance grows too loud (anyone out there felt it?). Thereâs a difference between a music level thatâs motivating, and a music level thatâs inhibiting, or even downright crushing.
Thrivecast: Thriveal Lab
My first Thrivecast appearance was to chat with two great hosts and great friends, Jason Blumer and Greg Kyte, about the newly christened Thriveal Lab and our first experiment on business model prototyping for the accounting profession.
In addition to the genesis and operation of the Lab, we talked about the principles of experimenting, and why accountants can find it hard even though it’s so necessary.
You can listen to the audio right from the page for Episode 38, and definitely be sure to subscribe to the Thrivecast for lots of great information, inspiration, and fun. If you’re an entrepreneurial-minded accountant, the Thriveal CPA Network is also a great way to connect with your tribe and grow - I highly recommend it!
Doodle in the Margins
When Iâm reading for content, Iâm all about the marginalia: underlines, questions in the borders, even one sided handÂwritten debates with the author. Which is why I was much relieved that the Kindle allows you to digitally underline text and add notes too â you can even export them to a PDF to save and search, a way cool feature that Iâve taken advantage of many a time.
But what if the text in a book went from edge to edge? No spaces between the lines, no space on either side of the page, none at the top, none at the bottom: a page littered with letters. Hard to read, cramped with lines blurring, and eyes crossingâŠ
Now imagine if that book is our firmâs story: tasks and activities wedged endÂtoÂend, no space inÂbetween, no real breaks, no room in the borders. When all the space is filled, thereâs no place to make edit markings. When all our resources are committed, thereâs no capacity for change. When the entire page is full, thereâs no space to doodle in the margins.
Referring Link: Lab Experiment 1 - Business Model Prototyping
Today I launched the inaugural experiment in the Thriveal Lab with the hypothesis that ‘there will be multiple successful business models for accounting firms of the future’. We discussed the premise and experiment framework, solicited experimental firms to participate, and thanked our founding Lab Partners for supporting the important work of the Lab.
Check out the original post for more!
Referring link: The Phrase That Will Change Your Business's Future
What is the ‘phrase that will change your business’s future?': âIâd like to try an experimentâŠletâs see if this works.â
In this post on the Thriveal blog, I announced the Self-Experiment Initiative of the Thriveal Lab – a structured way accounting firm owners could think through and design an experiment, and then record their results to a central repository to be shared with other experimenters.
Read more about the initiative and the surrounding tools and concepts in the original post.
How to not be Strategic, Strategically
Thereâs a balance line somewhere between having everything planned out and having no idea whatâs going on.
And the ideal is not âhaving it all figured out.â Thereâs no reason to feel bad or punish yourself for not being fully organized. Chaos is a natural part of the picture â you canât pull order from chaos without a little chaos. Which is why itâs okay to deliberately mess things up now and then. Or as we say in Thriveal parlance: blow things up.
When asked the question, âWhat does your firm want to be when it grows up,â itâs okay to say, âI donât know.â Discovery really best happens from the side rather than head-on. You really canât plan âa-haâ moments, or else itâs not really a discovery. Discovery is, by nature, unexpected. All you can do is put yourself in different places or situations where it might occur and remain open to it happening, without compulsion. A little trust in Providence doesnât hurt either.